It depends where you get tagged is probably the short answer. Gentleman, you know what we’re talking about…
The impact of arrows is similar to that of a boxing glove. It’s cushioned and makes more of a noise than anything else. A shot from very close range will leave a pink circle but that typically disappears in around 30 minutes.
Comparing arrow tag to paintball – you definitely won’t be left with the painful welts from a close range pellet!